Skip to content
*Title: Persistent Telegram Bot API 409 Conflict on Railway despite one replica
8dcyt2y9nr-sudo
OP

a month ago

Hi Railway team,

I'm running a Telegram bot on Railway and keep getting this error:

HTTP 409: Conflict: terminated by other getUpdates request; make sure that only one bot instance is running

Project ID: 6cb444b1-0888-4ecd-98e1-fdd6b50c314c

Relevant services:

  • Bot service ID: ba8a21cf-f2a5-49bd-bec5-25c2286de356
  • Telegram Bot API Server service ID: 86fc9362-b7fa-48a0-acdc-acdf821b5d42

What I've checked:

  • The bot service is configured with one replica.
  • The project has only one environment (production).
  • The bot service logs show Database ready and ReelsUni started, followed by repeated HTTP 409 errors.
  • The Telegram Bot API Server is running in local mode (--local) with a file bridge on port 8081.
  • I checked the payment service. Its recent logs show Gunicorn starting, with no visible getUpdates errors.
  • The error persists after redeploying the bot service.

Could you help me verify whether there are overlapping deployments, duplicate running containers, or another Railway-side issue that could explain the repeated getUpdates conflict?

I understand that the error may also be caused by another process using the same bot token outside Railway. I'd appreciate help ruling out Railway deployment or runtime issues first.

I have not included any bot tokens or secret environment variable values for security reasons.

Thank you!

Solved$10 Bounty

Pinned Solution

Do you have an instance of the bot running in a local environment?

Make sure there aren't any other instances of the bot running asides from that instance in Railway.

3 Replies

Railway
BOT

a month ago

This thread has been opened as a bounty so the community can help solve it.

Status changed to Open Railway • about 1 month ago


Do you have an instance of the bot running in a local environment?

Make sure there aren't any other instances of the bot running asides from that instance in Railway.


qbliliyu-gif

a month ago

A persistent 409 from getUpdates is definitive: Telegram is receiving a second long-poll request for the same bot token. The Telegram Bot API server itself does not consume updates merely because it is running with --local; one or more client processes are polling through it or through api.telegram.org.

Use this isolation sequence so you can distinguish Railway overlap from an external process without exposing the token:

  1. Stop the bot service completely (not redeploy) and wait longer than the library's polling timeout—normally 60–90 seconds. Keep the Bot API server running.
  2. Start only one bot deployment. In its startup logs, print a unique deployment marker such as RAILWAY_DEPLOYMENT_ID and the process ID, never the token. There should be exactly one marker and one polling loop.
  3. Check the service's Deployments view: only the newest deployment should be Active. A rolling redeploy can briefly overlap old and new pollers, but it cannot explain a conflict that continues after the old deployment has drained.
  4. Inspect every process in the bot container (ps -ef) and every service that has access to the same token. Common causes are Gunicorn starting the polling code once per worker, a separate worker and web service both importing the bot startup module, or a local development process still using the production token. Ensure polling starts only under one dedicated worker entrypoint—not at module import time.
  5. Check getWebhookInfo. If a webhook is configured while you intend to use polling, remove it once with deleteWebhook?drop_pending_updates=false, then start the single poller. Do not post the token or full URL here.
  6. If one clean Railway deployment still receives 409 after all other Railway services are stopped, rotate the bot token with BotFather and update only the dedicated polling service. If the conflict disappears, an unknown external process had the old token.

For your topology, the highest-probability cause is that the polling startup is executed in more than one application process/service, not the --local Telegram API server itself. A useful confirmation is to share the redacted startup command, replica count, Gunicorn worker count, and one log line containing the Railway deployment ID.

AI assistance disclosure: this response was prepared with AI assistance and checked against Telegram Bot API long-polling semantics before posting.


sundayabasi684-byte
Top 10% Contributor

a month ago

Railway documentation confirms that scaling services via replicas or environment variables instantiates separate container runtimes, but a Telegram 409 Conflict error originates entirely from application-level long-polling logic.

Even with a single replica set in Railway, a 409 error happens when multiple execution threads inside your container code simultaneously execute getUpdates requests using the same bot token. This commonly occurs if your WSGI/ASGI server runs multiple background worker processes that independently trigger the startup loop, or if module imports initialize the bot poller multiple times.

To resolve it, ensure your long-polling loop is restricted to a single process worker or migrate the service to use Telegram webhooks so multiple application instances can handle incoming traffic without session collisions.

AI-assisted; checked against Railway documentation and settings.


Status changed to Solved 0x5b62656e5d • 17 days ago


Welcome!

Sign in to your Railway account to join the conversation.

Loading...