I wonder if it's a configuration within your code and or whatever web framework you're using <:Thinking:1360710341239242762>

N/A

I am using nestjs

I didnt set anything

its working fine on my machine

what do you use to parse requests?

basic fetch api

no no, on your server

I get this error when I try to use fetch

somewhere in the app

not when I try to response

I think thats what you mean if not sorry I didnt get the question

when you make a request to your server, your server receives the request and parses it to make it understandable, typically you have some sort of parser like body-parser or a json parser to make sense of the request, and these parsers often have preset limits that you can increase - my theory is that, since you said you didn't set anything, you likely haven't changed the default limit on these meaning that your body size could exceed the predefined limit; the solution here would be to increase the limit

yeah okay I have bodyParser I set its limits to 50 mb

but what I am saying is I get this error when I try to send a request to some other server within my server. I attach 1k strings to the request for that other server and I think it blocks me from sending because of 1k strings

what other server? is it your server or a server someone else owns?

no basically I make another request to some other origin

and I put 1000 strings (each 64 bytes) and it complains about that body

its not a problem of me parsing the ongoing request to my server

its a problem that occurs when I try to make a request from my server to other API

what other API? is it your API or an API someone else owns?

no its an RPC that is owned by someone else

I just got this error on my railway log

If it's someone elses server then they'd need to increase the request limit or you'd need to send less data

unfortunately there's nothing Railway can do about this cause its not within Railway's control what that other API server deems as "too large"

no I really dont thing thats an issue on their part

it works fine

on my local machine

when I run the server

its something that railway blocks me from sending a request that has body size which is bigger than X

I assure you it's not something Railway is blocking, it's something the other API server you mention is blocking

Okay then why am I not getting the same error when I use it on my local

I'm not sure, maybe you send different data when testing it locally

no its exactly the same data

same configs

I really think its something with nginx configurations

I can check with a Railway team member if you want me to, but I'm very confident Railway doesn't interfere with your requests

would you like me to check with a team member?

I mean I guess because I am really stuck and I have to figure this out

Alright, then I'll get back to you once I get a response

thanks a lot

no problem 🙂

Alright, team member got back to me and confirmed what I was saying,

He explained that a 413 status code is on layer 7 (of the OSI model), this is the layer that holds all application-level protocols (HTTP, FTP, SSH, SMTP). When your container on Railway makes a request, the request leaving the container is only operating on layer 3 (holding lower-level protocols like IP, and ICMP), naturally on this layer there is no such thing as status codes because status codes (like 413, the error you're seeing) is a concept that only exists on HTTP (which is on layer 7).

Since Railway only handles traffic up until layer 3, there is no way for Railway to respond with a 413 status code because that doesn't happen until you reach layer 7 and by the time your request reaches layer 7 your request would be far out of Railway's reach.

In conclusion, it not only means Railway doesn't interfere with your requests (like I was saying), but it also means Railway couldn't interfere with your request (in the same way you're seeing) even if they wanted to. Ultimately meaning that it is definitely the server you're trying to reach responding with 413, which means you should talk to the developers and or support behind that server (or send less data).

okay I see but I still dont understand why does this work on mine

without any problem

It's hard to say, but you should really talk to them if you want to get to the bottom of it because Railway is definitely not interfering with the request. For all we know they could be adjusting the upload limit depending on whether the IP is a residential or datacentre IP address, you'll never know unless you ask

Okay I see thanks a lot for the help and time

Happy to help, best of luck

!s