N/A

Here's my fetch

1265762453694976070

and here's the result

you are calling templateDeploy aka v1, you should call templateDeployV2 with the correct serialized config structure

aah, didnt know there was a v2

thanks, ill look into it!

i cant seem to find templatedeployv2 in the graphiql docs?

it really does not want me to use it

use the internal endpoint

Where is the internal endpoint?

Aha, thanks! I hope i can figure it out

a surefire way would be just to simply watch the network calls the dashboard makes

i would love to know your usecase though?

Yeah, i tried that, but it uses the v1 deployment which is a bit weird

We're making a SaaS app, that has a seperate instance per customer

We've already got r2 buckets + turnstile working, so railways the last step to get the db + front & back up

and you want to deploy a template automatically on sign up or something?

So we can just click 1 button that sets up an entire instance

Yea

Or well, we click the create button

single tenant app eh?

Yeah, we built an app for 1 client and are scaling it to work for multiple

And we thought this'd be cool

( and look good on our portfolios )

you dont think your time would be better spent converting it to a multi tenant app for better scalability?

Ehh, maybe

But it'd take a while

Cause its a pretty big app

Entire radio management system

And we're not planning on a lot of clientd

fair enough

And we just thought this would be fun haha

1266084955973353582

This is only the sidebar

damn

hey i have an idea

👂

lol my cli is out of date, one sec

oooo

Yea that'd be way easier

what language where you planning to write the code to deploy a template in?

Node

then you could call out to the cli

(or bun if we're specific <:bun:1150878419282821313> )

Yeah, i'll try that probablh

bun has great support for calling out to cli apps doesnt it?

Oh yeah they introduced that lately

I'll see how it goes!

let me know too!

https://bun.sh/docs/runtime/shell 👀

Will do

hi @Brody im continuing to harrass you, we got it (mostly) working, however the deployed template is deploying everything with docker instead of github for some reason.

so for example, we have a github repo called user/repo, but its instead read as dockerhub user/repo

is that a bug with railway(cli) or an issue on our end

let's see a service source in your template?

then yeah it's an issue with the cli, please open an issue on the repo and I will notify the person who implemented the command

https://github.com/railwayapp/cli/issues/520

perfect thanks!

@Danny just to confirm again, you have deployed this exact same template in the dashboard just fine?

yep

@evan - the cli's deploy command is deploying GitHub repo's as docker images

!t

ack’d

this may just be a visual bug

oh yeah? I'm out so I can't test right now

thanks for the deets - i’ll follow up later tonight once i’ve dug in a bit more

I'll test when I can and update with more info too

<:hmm:1228339204048814080> looking at this again - i think the UI might make sense here? since you're deploying via CLI, we're keying off of that

(even though it is a template)

sorry but im not quite getting you, what do you mean exactly

this template is getting deployed via the cli, right? (like, that is the trigger)

yea thats correct

so - even though it is connected to a source repository (ie. the template), you're manually triggering a CLI deployment

so we're keying off of that

does that make sense?

yeh, that makes sense, but i still think its a bug. when i deployed it did show some connection to a source, but it was dockerhub user/repo instead of github user/repo

do you mind sending me a link to the project?

a thanks, yh thats basically the same

o ye das weird

thx brody

will dive in 🏊‍♂️

heya, sorry for the ping but any updates just yet? we're kinda stuck with our project right now, no pressure of course

this shouldn’t be blocking - the deploy still goes out?

it blocks our deploy, because it attempts do deploy via docker, which wil lalways fail

hmm ok i thought it was just a visual thing - do you have the link to your project?

give me a sec, ill generate one

can just copy the url and send it here

sum small bugfixes later https://railway.app/project/9e8dfc9b-6e9e-4b3e-9b7a-0e005c42d096

while its set to gh from the templates

its not a visual bug, because it actually deploys images via docker

lookin

oh and it also seems like its not even trying to deploy? that might just be from the missing docker image tho

so how do you actually want this to deploy?

i want this to deploy via my github repo i have set in the template

it is a private repo, but it should work fine as im authorized to access it from my acc

might be causing the issue tho

it says "source image" in the config

so that's why it is trying to deploy as an image

yh thats the issue

swap that to be source repo

can you link me to the template?

you can unblock yourself here by swapping to the gh repo?

yea i can, but we're creating these projects programmatically, so that wouldnt really solve the main issue. ill do it ig so i can continue testng on 1 instance

could i send it in DM? its not really a public template

if it isn't a public template, nobody will be able to access it

(i will be able to see it b/c admin)

oh i can access it from incognito, prob didnt set it as a private template then <:PES3_Smile:771029769268494378>

will need to see the template to understand further

alr https://railway.app/template/fi0ltx

404?

uhh

thats weird

https://railway.app/template/fI0ltx

is it a published template?

ok got it now

idk whats different bout the urls but the second one works somehow

second character is i vs l in second link i think

hmm nvm case sensitivity

aaa my clipboard lowercased it for some reason haha

nice

and you said if you deploy through the dashboard, its fine?

yep

odd

ok i've captured this all and the team member who has built all of the template stuff is on-call starting tmrw, so they should have some better context on what's going wrong here than myself

alrighty, thanku

but if you want to unblock any dev beyond deploying the template, just swap it in the dashboard to be the gh repo source obvi

yep, will do

also - you may want to look into environments depending on your use case? may be more helpful than creating projects

hmm yh that might be a good one

ill look into it

.

Confirming I understand correctly. There is a template which works fine upon deploying via the dashboard but doesn't work properly when deploying via the CLI.

Correct, the template has a service with a GitHub source, when deployed from the dashboard the service is deployed from GitHub, but when deploying the same template from the cli it's treated as an image source and it tries to pull it from the registry

Seems like the attached repos don't exist anymore? Is this using private repos?

example project and template

yeah it's private, not sure if that's a factor

Could you check if you can reproduce it with a template with a public repo?

I can tomorrow as it's quite late for me (3:40am)

You should sleep. 😴

I've checked + reproduced with a template with a public repo.

I've PR-ed a fix (https://github.com/railwayapp/cli/pull/523). Will merge upon review as I've never written Rust before.

Should be fixed in the latest release. Could you try it and let me know?

(v3.11.2) - release is still running

Was fixed in 3.11.1 no?

.2 is JRs.

haha i know but it caught me off guard <:kekw:788259314607325204>

update, works!