Skip to content
Fred API
undertowindex
OP

a month ago

I’m running a cron worker on Railway that needs to fetch economic data from the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) API at api.stlouisfed.org. This is a public government endpoint that provides historical and real-time economic indicators (interest rates, financial stress indices, etc.) with no authentication required.

The Problem:

When the cron job attempts to reach https://api.stlouisfed.org/, the request consistently fails with:

403 CONNECT tunnel failed

The same request works fine from my local machine and other cloud providers, which suggests Railway’s outbound proxy is blocking this specific endpoint.

Error Details:

Endpoint: api.stlouisfed.org (HTTPS port 443)

Error: HTTP 403 “CONNECT tunnel failed”

Endpoint accessibility: Publicly accessible, no geoblocking or authentication requirements

Failure rate: Consistent, 100%

Why This Matters:

The cron job depends on this data for daily reporting. Without access, it falls back to cached or default values, which degrades output quality.

Request:

Could you please allowlist api.stlouisfed.org on the outbound proxy so HTTPS requests to this endpoint can pass through?

Additional Context:

FRED is a public, non-commercial government API

No credentials or authentication in requests (public access)

This appears to be a proxy firewall/whitelist rule issue

thank you to all

$10 Bounty

5 Replies

Railway
BOT

a month ago

This thread has been opened as a bounty so the community can help solve it.

Status changed to Open Railway • about 1 month ago


reacx-research

a month ago

The error points to a failed HTTP CONNECT tunnel through a forward proxy; it does not yet establish that Railway is blocking FRED. A CONNECT rejection happens before the HTTPS request reaches FRED.

One correction: FRED's documented API requires an API key. For the v1 endpoints it is the api_key parameter: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/api_key.html . A missing key needs fixing, but would not explain this CONNECT failure.

Could you confirm these three things so we can locate the actual restriction?

  1. Does the error come from the deployed cron process itself, or from an IDE/AI tool making the request? Which HTTP library produces it?
  2. In that service, are HTTP_PROXY, HTTPS_PROXY, ALL_PROXY or their lowercase equivalents set? Please share only set/unset, never their values or credentials. Python urllib, for example, automatically uses proxy environment settings: https://docs.python.org/3/library/urllib.request.html#urllib.request.ProxyHandler .
  3. Is the workspace on a verified Full Trial, a Limited Trial, or another plan? Limited Trial outbound restrictions are documented here: https://docs.railway.com/pricing/free-trial . A FREE label alone doesn't tell us which applies.

With those details, we can distinguish application/tool proxy settings from Railway trial restrictions and an actual destination-side response. I cannot change Railway's network rules from a community reply.

AI-assisted reply; the cited documentation and explanation were reviewed. I have not tested a request inside your Railway service.


undertowindex
OP

a month ago

thank you for your reply. Answers to your three questions:

  1. Error source and HTTP library: Python’s requests library (deployed cron process). The calls to https://api.stlouisfed.org/fred/series/observations are wrapped in exception handling that catches and logs the CONNECT error.

  2. Proxy environment variables: The code doesn’t explicitly set or override proxy behavior — requests automatically respects HTTPS_PROXY if set in the environment. No explicit proxy configuration in the code.

  3. Plan type: Hobby Plan (paid), not Limited Trial. So trial-based outbound restrictions don’t apply.

On the API key: I reviewed the code — it DOES include the api_key parameter in every FRED request. However, here’s the critical question: Is FRED_API_KEY actually populated in the deployed service’s environment variables?

If that environment variable isn’t set, the API key would be empty even though the code is passing it. That could cause the FRED API to reject the request. Without it, even a paid plan’s outbound connectivity wouldn’t matter.

Could you confirm whether FRED_API_KEY is set in your Railway service environment? If it is, and we’re still getting 403 CONNECT errors on a paid Hobby plan, that suggests a deeper networking configuration issue worth investigating.


Anonymous

a month ago

An empty FRED_API_KEY cannot cause the CONNECT rejection. The proxy rejects the tunnel before Requests sends the API query to FRED.

Your follow-up states that the code does not configure a proxy. It does not show whether the deployed process inherits one.

Run this immediately before the existing FRED request in the deployed cron process:

import os
from requests.utils import get_environ_proxies, select_proxy

url = "https://api.stlouisfed.org/fred/series/observations"
print("FRED_API_KEY_present:", bool(os.getenv("FRED_API_KEY", "").strip()))
print("environment_proxy_selected:", bool(select_proxy(url, get_environ_proxies(url))))

This makes no network request. It prints only two booleans. The proxy check accounts for environment proxy settings and NO_PROXY for this destination.

If environment_proxy_selected is True, inspect the service's inherited proxy configuration. Correct an unintended proxy setting, or ask the proxy operator to permit api.stlouisfed.org:443.

If FRED_API_KEY_present is False, configure that key separately. A missing key still needs correction, but it does not explain the failed tunnel.

If proxy selection is False, check the actual Session configuration or request wrapper next. Please share only the two booleans, not credentials or full exception URLs.

Source: https://requests.readthedocs.io/en/latest/user/advanced/#proxies

AI-assisted answer. I tested five configuration cases and reproduced a 403 CONNECT rejection locally with empty and nonempty fake keys. I cannot inspect your Railway service.


undertowindex
OP

a month ago

thank you, this is what i got back.

FRED_API_KEY_present: True

environment_proxy_set: False

Current error: HTTP 400 Bad Request from FRED API


duetmain

a month ago

That new result changes the diagnosis: an HTTP 400 returned by FRED needs its response body checked. A populated key is not necessarily a registered, valid key.

FRED gives the reason in JSON’s error_message or XML’s error/message attribute. Add this after your existing request, before raise_for_status(); rename r to your response variable:

import os, re
import xml.etree.ElementTree as ET
from urllib.parse import quote

try:
    data = r.json()
    msg = data.get("error_message", "") if isinstance(data, dict) else ""
except ValueError:
    try:
        msg = ET.fromstring(r.text).attrib.get("message", "")
    except ET.ParseError:
        msg = ""
msg = str(msg or "No FRED error message; inspect privately.")
key = os.getenv("FRED_API_KEY", "").strip()
if key:
    for secret in (key, quote(key, safe="")):
        msg = msg.replace(secret, "[redacted]")
msg = re.sub(r"\b[a-zA-Z0-9]{32}\b", "[redacted]", msg)
print("FRED status:", r.status_code)
print("FRED error:", msg[:500])

This makes no additional request. Inspect the output privately before sharing only the sanitized error, never the URL or credentials.

If the message says the key is unregistered, correct the api_key actually supplied in params. If it names series_id, dates or another parameter, fix that field. To isolate optional parameters, try one request with only your registered api_key, series_id=GNPCA, file_type=json and limit=1. If that succeeds, add your original options back individually.

Official error format: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/errors.html

Endpoint parameters: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/docs/api/fred/series_observations.html

AI-assisted reply. I verified the docs and tested this extraction/redaction logic against eight synthetic response cases locally. I have not accessed your service or reproduced its live 400; the failing parameter is still unconfirmed.


Welcome!

Sign in to your Railway account to join the conversation.

Loading...