Hey, any reason on why you're using MinIO while Railway has buckets?

Also appears to be somewhat sunset:

Mainly because of region, I'm serving asian people

Railway has support for Amsterdam

That's still EU though

Oh yeah you're right sorry, forgot about the Singapore region.

there is a singapore region

All good

what's your usecase for minio?

if its serving public files i would suggest using something else

if its serving private files i would also suggest using something else

Can't find it though, I saw the same as @ThallesComH

Storing audio and images that user uploads

We're talking about Railway buckets here

use real s3

Anyway, your vars should be:

MINIO_ENDPOINT=${{RAILWAY_PUBLIC_DOMAIN}}
MINIO_PORT= 
MINIO_PUBLIC_URL=https://${{RAILWAY_PUBLIC_DOMAIN}}/

aw rip

Want to keep anything on Railway if possible

real s3 has a sg region

If it still does not work after that, ensure that MinIO is listening on 0.0.0.0 and not something like 127.0.0.1

• more expensive,
• less reliable
• no sg region

you're writing s3-compatible code anyways

That's not recommended as it uses the public network and will occur bandwidth charges

Yea looking for private

Oh right, sorry, I thought this was for public stuff.

are you doing file processing?

or just serving

You should use RAILWAY_PRIVATE_DOMAIN in that case

what a doozy

lmfao

you can't make this shit up

Serving

<:vvv:254194425754812416>

this is crazy

😂

Let's keep this thread clean please 🙏

this is relevant?

Egress really isn't that expensive if you're putting a CDN in front.

Basically this

I don't remember the exact port though

I tried doesn't seem to work

Would it not be whatever port the application is listening on?

Yeah

Buckets are back.

^In response to Alex's messages

Got it, that would be the port 9000

Buckets have no existence here <:Peepo_Cry:832227339161174027>

Pairing through threads saw a forwarded incident <:salute:1137099685417451530>

wait has sg never had buckets

i might be stupid

So,

MINIO_ENDPOINT=${{.RAILWAY_PRIVATE_DOMAIN}}
MINIO_PORT=${{.MINIO_PRIVATE_PORT}}
MINIO_PUBLIC_URL=${{.MINIO_PUBLIC_ENDPOINT}}

Let me try that

thanks for clarifying thalles

Wouldn't MINI_PUBLIC_URL still cost egress?

If you need to serve public files to your users (e.g., assets for a browser), then egress charges will be inevitable. If you only need to upload files to or download files from your service to MinIO, then a private network is the way to go.

In my previous application, I implemented both setups: one for uploading/downloading files internally and another to allow users to download files directly.

https://discord.com/channels/713503345364697088/1458208636609368220/1459384958408720462