10 months ago
What I need
MINIO_ENDPOINT
MINIO_PORT
MINIO_USE_SSL
MINIO_ACCESS_KEY
MINIO_SECRET_KEY
MINIO_BUCKET
MINIO_PUBLIC_URL
What I'm struggling is MINIO_ENDPOINT, MINIO_PORT and MINIO_PUBLIC_URL
Using the public endpoint works fine but when I want to host it on railway, it can't seem to connect. Which environment variables I need for these 3?
57 Replies
10 months ago
Hey, any reason on why you're using MinIO while Railway has buckets?
10 months ago
10 months ago
Also appears to be somewhat sunset:
10 months ago
Railway has support for Amsterdam
10 months ago
Oh yeah you're right sorry, forgot about the Singapore region.
10 months ago
there is a singapore region
10 months ago
what's your usecase for minio?
10 months ago
if its serving public files i would suggest using something else
10 months ago
if its serving private files i would also suggest using something else
10 months ago
We're talking about Railway buckets here
10 months ago
use real s3
10 months ago
Anyway, your vars should be:
MINIO_ENDPOINT=${{RAILWAY_PUBLIC_DOMAIN}}
MINIO_PORT=
MINIO_PUBLIC_URL=https://${{RAILWAY_PUBLIC_DOMAIN}}/10 months ago
aw rip
10 months ago
real s3 has a sg region
10 months ago
If it still does not work after that, ensure that MinIO is listening on 0.0.0.0 and not something like 127.0.0.1
10 months ago
- more expensive,
- less reliable
- no sg region
10 months ago
you're writing s3-compatible code anyways
10 months ago
That's not recommended as it uses the public network and will occur bandwidth charges
10 months ago
Oh right, sorry, I thought this was for public stuff.
10 months ago
are you doing file processing?
10 months ago
or just serving
10 months ago
You should use RAILWAY_PRIVATE_DOMAIN in that case
10 months ago
what a doozy
10 months ago
10 months ago
lmfao
10 months ago
you can't make this shit up
10 months ago
<:vvv:254194425754812416>
10 months ago
this is crazy
10 months ago
😂
10 months ago
Let's keep this thread clean please 🙏
10 months ago
this is relevant?
10 months ago
Egress really isn't that expensive if you're putting a CDN in front.
10 months ago
Basically this
10 months ago
I don't remember the exact port though
10 months ago
Would it not be whatever port the application is listening on?
10 months ago
Yeah
10 months ago
Buckets are back.
^In response to Alex's messages
10 months ago
Got it, that would be the port 9000
10 months ago
Buckets have no existence here <:Peepo_Cry:832227339161174027>
10 months ago
Pairing through threads saw a forwarded incident <:salute:1137099685417451530>
10 months ago
wait has sg never had buckets
10 months ago
i might be stupid
10 months ago
So,
MINIO_ENDPOINT=${{.RAILWAY_PRIVATE_DOMAIN}}
MINIO_PORT=${{.MINIO_PRIVATE_PORT}}
MINIO_PUBLIC_URL=${{.MINIO_PUBLIC_ENDPOINT}}10 months ago
thanks for clarifying thalles
10 months ago
If you need to serve public files to your users (e.g., assets for a browser), then egress charges will be inevitable. If you only need to upload files to or download files from your service to MinIO, then a private network is the way to go.
In my previous application, I implemented both setups: one for uploading/downloading files internally and another to allow users to download files directly.
10 months ago
Status changed to Solved brody • 10 months ago