Hey there! We've found the following might help you get unblocked faster:

• 🧵 RQ Worker Connects to Redis but Fails to Dequeue from Specific Queue (summarize_tasks)

If you find the answer from one of these, please let us know by solving the thread!

Hello,

While I cannot provide architecture support to help you build your application, I can recommend looking into Celery for task scheduling.

Best,

Brody

Let me refine my question. Can I deploy a 2 railway services from a single python fastapi repo:

1. for the API server
2. for a redis worker that I can scale the number of instances of

Can i do this from a single railway.json to define two railway services with two separate start commands?

You cannot use a single railway.json to define two services, but that doesn't matter much, as that approach is not required.

This would be considered a monorepo setup. Please see our docs on how you would deploy that.

https://docs.railway.com/tutorials/deploying-a-monorepo

I'm already using a monorepo setup but this is more nuanced, which is why I'm confused. The way python job queues seem to be built (e.g. Celery, Dramatiq, etc) is a little different than clean /frontend and /backend folders.

They seem to run via the same folder i.e like /fastapi but require different start commands depending on the service: API (my fastapi server), workers (my actual ETL jobs), GUI for the jobs (Celery's flower GUI).

Commands (examples)

-[Queue GUI] flower -A worker.celery_app --port=5555

-[Server] uvicorn app.main:app --host 0.0.0.0 --port 8000

-[Worker] celery -A worker.celery_app worker -l info -Q etl -c <concurrency>

There's some nuance to this that I'm not understanding how to deploy on Railway. Is the practice here deploying the same folder as 3 distinct services with 3 distinct start commands? That seems wonky/incorrect.

Gotcha, you can right-click your existing service on the project canvas and duplicate it, then change the start command in its service settings.

https://docs.railway.com/overview/the-basics#service-settings

https://docs.railway.com/reference/build-and-start-commands#start-command

Hey, I am trying to modify my deploy commands for my duplicated fastapi service

1. worker -- i want to change this deploy command

2. fastapi server -- keep whats in railway.json

3. queue ui -- i want to change this deploy command

It's in my @proto-os project in my develop environment