24 days ago
Hello Railway team,
I'm using Railway CLI v5.71.0 on the Hobby plan.
When attempting to list files on an existing persistent volume, the CLI reports that the attached service has no active deployment.
Is there an officially supported way to export the volume's files without starting the original application or modifying the volume?
If a temporary recovery deployment is required, could you explain the safest procedure and whether it can be performed entirely within the monthly usage included in the Hobby plan, without additional charges?
Please provide general guidance. I prefer not to share project identifiers or infrastructure details publicly.
Thank you.
3 Replies
Status changed to Awaiting Railway Response Railway • 24 days ago
24 days ago
The CLI's volume file commands work through the service the volume is attached to, so they need that service to have an active deployment. They can't read a stored volume directly, and we don't currently offer a way to export a volume's files without a running deployment on its attached service.
On cost, the Hobby plan includes $5 of resource usage each month. You're only charged extra if your total usage for the billing cycle goes over $5, so a short deployment costs nothing extra as long as everything you run that cycle (CPU, memory, egress and volume storage) stays within that amount. Builds aren't billed. We can't guarantee a particular deployment will stay within the $5 because that depends on what else is running, but you can set usage limits to cap your spend. Pricing details are on our plans page.
Status changed to Awaiting User Response Railway • 24 days ago
Railway
The CLI's volume file commands work through the service the volume is attached to, so they need that service to have an active deployment. They can't read a stored volume directly, and we don't currently offer a way to export a volume's files without a running deployment on its attached service. On cost, the Hobby plan includes $5 of resource usage each month. You're only charged extra if your total usage for the billing cycle goes over $5, so a short deployment costs nothing extra as long as everything you run that cycle (CPU, memory, egress and volume storage) stays within that amount. Builds aren't billed. We can't guarantee a particular deployment will stay within the $5 because that depends on what else is running, but you can [set usage limits](https://docs.railway.com/pricing/cost-control) to cap your spend. Pricing details are on our [plans page](https://docs.railway.com/pricing/plans).
24 days ago
Thank you for clarifying.
The issue is still unresolved. I understand that volume file access requires an active deployment and that the Hobby plan includes $5 of monthly resource usage.
However, I cannot authorize any additional charges or risk modifying the original volume data.
Could a Railway engineer please confirm:
- Whether any supported recovery or export option exists without deploying or modifying the original service.
- If not, whether a temporary inspection-only deployment on the existing service can safely access the original volume without starting the application, replacing the volume, or altering stored data.
- Whether there is a way to enforce a strict zero-overage limit within the Hobby plan's included usage.
Please provide guidance only. I am not authorizing any deployment, volume changes, or additional paid services.
Thank you.
Status changed to Awaiting Railway Response Railway • 24 days ago
24 days ago
There's no supported way to export or list a volume's files without an active deployment on the service it's attached to. The CLI volume file commands go through that service's running deployment, not straight to the stored volume.
We don't offer an inspection-only deployment mode. We can't confirm any procedure that lets a deployment on that service mount the volume while guaranteeing the application never starts and the stored data is never changed.
A hard usage limit can't be set to exactly the Hobby plan's included $5. The minimum hard limit is $10, and once usage reaches the limit, all workloads are taken offline. So a hard limit caps your spend, but it can't guarantee zero charges beyond the included usage. You can also set a custom email alert at a lower amount, which notifies you without stopping anything. Details are on the cost control page.
Status changed to Awaiting User Response Railway • 24 days ago
17 days ago
This thread has been marked as solved automatically due to a lack of recent activity. Please re-open this thread or create a new one if you require further assistance. Thank you!
Status changed to Solved Railway • 17 days ago